Tag Archives: Zionism

Israel: D-7

A week before my first trip to Israel and I am nervous and excited. Excited to finally visit the place that is so central to my prayers and rituals. Nervous that my expectations will not be met and I will disappointed in a place that I want so badly to love and embrace. The trip feels like a pilgrimage of sorts, a coming home, a return to something my heart needs. At the same time, though, I want to be dispassionate and not demand too much: I don’t want to risk losing the Israel of my prayers.

I am incredibly lucky to be able to make this maiden visit with members of my synagogue. The itinerary is stimulating and challenging and exactly the way I wanted my first trip to be. The question framing our trip is: “How does a country dealing with the basic existential question of survival not only hold on to its basic declaration of intent – to be a state both Jewish and democratic – but also create, build, thrive and grow?” We will travel the length and breadth of Israel with this question in mind, not looking for faults, but trying to uncover complexities: seeking to understand how it is possible to be Jewish, progressive, and Zionist in this most complex of societies. Wrestling with this question will be a journey that I hope will increase my connection with the State of Israel and teach me more about myself and the place my heart calls home…I can’t wait to get there.

Is Jewish Critique Possible?

Is it possible to be a Jewish intellectual?
How do concepts such as ‘ahavat Israel’ and ‘solidarity for the Jewish people’ square with the need for intellectuals to remain detached from their national or religious group to retain their moral integrity?

By Professor Eva Illouz

In a famous exchange between Gershom Scholem and Hannah Arendt, the scholar of Jewish mysticism accused the political theorist of not having enough “ahavat Israel” (love for the Jewish nation and people). What did Arendt do to deserve such a supreme insult? She had written a series of articles for The New Yorker on the Eichmann trial, published in 1963 as a short book called “Eichmann in Jerusalem.”

Continue reading Is Jewish Critique Possible?